Open now · until 8 PMToday 11 AM – 8 PM
Fresh coastal flavors in historic downtown Newburgh
At The Tin Fish, we bring the coast to your table with fresh seafood delivered up to six days a week. Oysters, seafood platters, cocktails and more — in a casual, welcoming room or out on the patio.
Newburgh’s seafood spot for twenty years
Delivered up to six days a week
Blue Points and a specialty oyster every week
A casual, welcoming room or the patio
Off the boat, on the board
The specials change with the catch. When they’re gone, they’re gone — call ahead and we’ll tell you what’s left.
Icy-cold piles of chubby oysters, shucked to order
Blue Points from the Chesapeake Bay are our house oyster, and a specialty oyster joins them on the ice every week. Pull up a seat at the bar, order a dozen and a cold one, and we’ll bring them to you.
Fried
Fried Oysters · As an appetizer
$12.75
On a platter
Oysters · Fried, with slaw, tartar & cocktail
F$21.50
In a handheld
Oyster · With cole slaw
$14.75
With fish
Fish & Oysters · The fried combo
$19.10
Shucked to order and served on ice.
Blue Point
Our house oyster, from the Chesapeake Bay, Virginia.
Specialty Oysters
Varies weekly. Ask us what's on ice today.
Changing the tide in Newburgh's seafood scene
A local favorite and a premier seafood destination in the Evansville area for twenty years.
Independently owned and operated in historic downtown Newburgh, Chef Morgan Close Castillo prides herself on the quality and consistency of her service and her coastal seafood menu, with fresh fish delivered daily.
The Tin Fish is a friendly, often bustling, always casual place to enjoy icy cold piles of chubby oysters, delicious seafood platters, wine by the glass, beer and smart cocktails.
2 pieces of fried cod, splashed with tartar sauce and hot sauce. Served on a toasted bun.
Just a Sandwich
$7.75Make it a Platter
$11.25Our famous Fish Sandwich served with fries and cole slaw.
Milton Sandwich
$8.50Make it a Milton: dressed with house made cole slaw.
Milton Platter
$11.75The Milton, with fries and cole slaw.
Housemade shrimp salad in an herby citrus mayonnaise, on a toasted brioche roll — on the handhelds board.
What Newburgh orders
Straight off our menu boards — prices as they are today.
No. 01Appetizers
12-Hour Wings
Braised, dry-rubbed.
$14.75
No. 02Handhelds
Coastal Shrimp Salad Roll
Housemade shrimp salad dressed lightly in an herby citrus mayonnaise dressing and served on a toasted brioche roll with lettuce and tomato.
$15.25
No. 03Seafood Platters
Fish & Chips
3 pc$12.99
No. 04Tacos
Fried Cod
T$7.80
No. 05Chowder
New England Clam Chowder
Cup$5.50
No. 06Fried Combos
Tin Fish Combo
$17.99
No. 07Appetizers
Catfish Bites
$10.25
No. 08Seafood Platters
Mixed Seafood Grill
Salmon, tilapia, mahi-mahi, shrimp and scallops.
G$22.25
Sip, savor & unwind
Wines by the glass, cold beer and signature cocktails — perfectly paired with your favorite seafood.
Coconut Mojito
Coconut Captain Morgan, coconut cream, mint, lime juice, soda
Pear Cognac Sour
Hennessy, pear liqueur, apple nectar, lemon juice, Fee Foam
Lemon Drops — Now on Tap
Fresh muddled lemon, Deep Eddy Lemon vodka, sugared rim
Russian Ginger
Absolut, Kahlúa, gingerbread simple, cream
Worth going out of your way
Helpful staff. Clean restaurant. Most important, they know how to perfectly cook seafood. Best oysters I've had outside Louisiana. This place is worth going out of your way.
If I could only pick one place to dine out, it would be Tin Fish, no question! The service is always above and beyond, it has a comfortable but stylish decor and vibe. Try the specials, and special sides — that is where you get even a little more of the good stuff!
Six Blue Point oysters were fresh. Good stuff. Cod fish and chips were hot and crispy. You order first at a counter, then they bring your food to you. Staff was very attentive.
We really enjoyed the patio — plenty of shaded spots or spots in the sun. We got lobster mac and cheese bites to start, so yummy and crispy. Then we both got a blackened mahi-mahi sandwich on pumpernickel. Super flavorful and the fish was cooked perfectly! Their homemade hot sauce was a great addition. We will be back!
Order at the counter. We'll bring it to you.
Walk in, order at the register, grab a seat inside or out on the patio, and sit back. Parties of eight or more can reserve by phone.
Hours
Open now · until 8 PM
| Monday – Thursday | 11 AM – 8 PM |
|---|---|
| Friday – Saturday | 11 AM – 8:30 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM – 2 PM |